Score: 9

"Disappointing"

submission: The Greatest Idea Ever!

date: November 21, 2008

You open with a notepad that says, "boobies" multiple times and you don't even make the obvious "large hardon collider" joke? It's a joke that was aetup but had no punchline! Maybe the lack of the joke is the punchline...?

Nicely made Flash, though. The raster images (photos) at the end was kind of disappointing, though. You have all this great Flash artwork and then some bad image editing to finish it off. The particle beam coming from that donut thing particularly looked bad because of it, as well as the star field behind the Earth.

Score: 10

"Wow."

submission: Megaman - Rockin in paper

date: October 27, 2008

I want to rate this a 6/5.

Score: 4

"Needs a restart function"

submission: Orchestrated Death

date: October 9, 2008

Having to close the entire game just to reset a level is stupid.

Score: 10

"So good"

submission: =( Spun )=

date: October 14, 2009

Everything combines so nicely. It's actually rather inspiring, making me want to go finish a few projects.

Score: 7

"Generic"

submission: Morrowind Midwinter -ADJ-

date: December 3, 2008

The drum track seems rather generic. The song, on the whole, is rather repetitive; It's the same theme just being replayed with different instruments. It's not even the full theme, it's just the first half. It's all so very bland, it's almost a mockery.

And it's the main theme from Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind.

Score: 1

"Needs a lot of work."

submission: FF7 - JENOVA (8bit)

date: November 25, 2008

Honestly, it sounds like you just went to a video game midi site, downloaded a midi, and changed the instruments to something 8-bit. I'm not saying this because I looked around on such a midi site and found one that matches up with this one exactly, but because at 1:02 it sounds muddy with sound. It cease to be arranged music and just becomes noise.

I suggest you go back, tone down the probably 15 or so instruments you have going to something more manageable like 4 or 5. One of the "rules" of 8-bit music (on the NES, at least) is that you can only have FOUR notes playing at one time, or four-note polyphony. 8-bit composers typically used the four notes for four different channels (as attempting chords would have sounded horrendous): One channel might be the bassline, another the "piano" or lead/saw, and the other two for snares (static) or strings (sines).